Busted noses, damaged units: Texas police division routinely tough with the medically weak, lawsuit alleges


A broken dialysis system. A busted listening to assist. A roughed-up most cancers affected person. These allegations are included in a federal lawsuit filed this week in opposition to a Texas police division accused of routinely utilizing “extreme pressure on compliant civilians” — together with individuals with medical points.

The swimsuit, filed Thursday in U.S. District Courtroom for the Southern District of Texas by attorneys with the Nationwide Police Accountability Venture, claims that officers with the Rosenberg Police Division illegally detained a pair at gunpoint earlier than destroying, damaging or confiscating their belongings, together with the dialysis system, on Nov. 6, 2020.

Regina Armstead and Michael Lewis, who has kidney illness, mentioned the practically hour-long cease left them feeling “frightened, humiliated, embarrassed, and persecuted for being Black,” the swimsuit says.

Regina Armstead and Michael Lewis. The couple is suing the Rosenberg Police Division for illegally detaining them and damaging Lewis’ dialysis system.Courtesy Regina Armstead and Michael Lewis

Their expertise, based on the lawsuit, is typical for “many different civilians” within the metropolis of roughly 39,000, situated about 40 miles southwest of Houston.  

The pair, who had been driving dwelling after choosing up a meal, was stopped by authorities trying to find a white automotive linked to a bunch of armed teenagers, the swimsuit states.

Lewis and Armstead had been driving a white Dodge Charger however had been far older than the suspects: Armstead, a nursing assistant, is 57. Lewis, a retired Imperial Sugar supervisor, is 67. 

Nonetheless, Armstead was handcuffed and positioned within the patrol car at gunpoint with out clarification, the swimsuit alleges.

The couple alerted officers to the system in Lewis’ arm used to hook up with a dialysis machine — and the warning he’d obtained from medical doctors to not put something tight round his fingers or wrists, based on the swimsuit. 

“However they only saved doing what they needed to do,” Lewis instructed NBC Information.

The system, a fistula, malfunctioned after Lewis was detained, and he’s wanted eight to 10 procedures within the practically two years since to make sure his three-days-per-week therapy goes easily, he mentioned. Throughout a visit final month, he mentioned a stint needed to be inserted into his arm to “open up the vein.”

The couple was launched with out being charged, although the officers who searched their automotive confiscated Armstead’s cellphone with out telling her, she mentioned. 

And her key fob — which officers instructed her to drop — wound up crushed and down the highway, she mentioned. Armstead’s cellphone was returned, however the division has not paid the $270 substitute value of her key system, regardless of a number of requests, she mentioned.

“I hope this makes it higher for all of us, however particularly for individuals of shade,” Armstead mentioned of the lawsuit. “It’s not simply taking place to us.”

Neither Rosenberg’s chief of police nor the town’s mayor responded to requests for remark. The legislation agency that represents the town didn’t reply, and neither did two former police chiefs.

Telephone messages left at listed numbers for 4 of the officers named within the swimsuit went unreturned, and a fifth officer couldn’t be reached.

‘This isn’t a person officer’

An legal professional for the couple, Lauren Bonds, mentioned that what Lewis and Armstead went by means of reveals how the town’s police division operates with “no accountability.”

“This isn’t a person officer who’s flying beneath the radar,” she mentioned. “The town and police division have been unwilling to enhance their officers’ habits.”

The 5 officers concerned within the couple’s cease had been named in about 100 complaints in seven years, Bonds mentioned, citing information her authorized workforce obtained by means of a public data request. 

In a 2016 incident referenced within the swimsuit, a mom described an officer throwing her son’s cellphone on the bottom and breaking it whereas he tried to file a police response to a loud household cookout, Bonds mentioned. Two years in the past, officers “brandished pistols and rifles” at a bunch of unarmed individuals filming a music video, the swimsuit says.

Bonds mentioned the data request discovered no disciplinary measures related to the complaints.

NBC Information has not verified the allegations within the complaints. Neither the mayor nor the police chief responded to requests for remark. 

Bonds additionally pointed to a sequence of lawsuits filed in opposition to the division that spanned greater than a decade, together with some filed by people who find themselves disabled or have medical points. On this latter class, one of many circumstances was dismissed, one other was settled and a 3rd is ongoing.

A damaged listening to assist

In 2009, an off-duty police sergeant with listening to loss, from close by Richmond, was pulled over in Rosenberg, based on a federal lawsuit that the grasp sergeant, Robert Eiteman, filed. 

The swimsuit, which was talked about within the criticism filed by the Police Accountability Venture, was dismissed in 2013.

In an affidavit included within the swimsuit, Eiteman, who was sporting just one listening to assist on the time, mentioned he wasn’t instructed why he was stopped, and he believed he was following the officer’s directions when he positioned his fingers on prime of his automotive.

The officer, Justin Pannell, had truly instructed Eiteman to get again in his automotive — and what Pannell perceived as defiance prompted him to throw Eiteman to the bottom, based on a choose’s choice within the swimsuit. 

Pannell punched and handcuffed Eiteman, then positioned his knee on the sergeant’s head and neck whereas urgent his face into the asphalt, based on paperwork within the choice. Eiteman struggled to get into Pannell’s automotive, and the officer threatened to “tase” him, based on the choice.

Within the affidavit, Eiteman mentioned his one working listening to assist — which value $4,500 — was damaged throughout the encounter.

He was booked on suspicion of driving whereas intoxicated and resisting arrest, although he denied the allegations and the fees had been dismissed after a choose discovered there was no possible trigger to take him into custody, based on the choice. In a swimsuit filed in 2011, Eiteman claimed he was the sufferer of extreme pressure and false arrest.

“By no means did I think about that I might turn into the goal of a very aggressive, storm-trooping road cop with no regard for coverage,” he mentioned within the affidavit.

Attorneys representing the town denied the allegations, saying in a courtroom submitting that Pannell used a “cheap” stage of pressure when Eiteman didn’t adjust to verbal instructions. The choose agreed with the town, and in 2013, his lawsuit was dismissed. 

A message left on a cellphone quantity listed beneath Eiteman’s title was not returned, and the lawyer who represented him didn’t reply to a request for remark. Pannell, who left the division and now works for a personal investigations agency, didn’t reply to a request for remark.

Altercation with a most cancers affected person

A yr after Eiteman’s case was dismissed, a 51-year-old girl with a tool in her chest for administering cancer-fighting medicine was tackled by a Rosenberg police officer throughout a household dispute, based on a federal lawsuit filed in 2016 alleging extreme pressure and false arrest.

The swimsuit was additionally referenced by the Police Accountability Venture.

The dispute escalated right into a bodily confrontation when an officer instructed the girl’s husband to “again off” as he alerted officers to her situation, based on the swimsuit, which cited dashcam video. After the person, Steven Saenz, stepped again, an officer appeared to sort out him and started “pummeling” his head, inflicting him to quickly blackout, the swimsuit says.

One other officer tackled his spouse, Christine Saenz, based on the swimsuit.

In disturbing cellphone video supplied to NBC Information by the household’s lawyer, Steven Saenz could be seen on the bottom, his head bloody and an officer on prime of him. Christine Saenz seems to be on the bottom close by, yelling for her husband to “cease” as one other officer locations handcuffs on her.

Because the officers wrestle with Steven Saenz, Christine Saenz could be seen rising to her ft earlier than an officer throws her to the bottom. The identical officer can then be seen placing Steven Saenz within the head.

“She must be checked — she has most cancers,” the person recording the video, the couple’s son, could be heard saying a short while later.

On July 30, the Saenzes had been arrested on suspicion of assaulting a public servant and inflicting bodily damage, courtroom data present. Their son Brandon Alaniz was additionally arrested and accused of interfering with an officer. 

In a courtroom submitting included within the federal lawsuit, attorneys for the police division mentioned officers acted when Steven Saenz “bodily inserted himself” between an officer and his spouse. 

“Officers requested Mr. Saenz to step again and cease interfering however he refused to conform,” the submitting says, including that as an alternative, the couple assaulted the officers. Alaniz was taken into custody for “repeatedly interfering” with the investigation, the doc says.

Courtroom data present that each one however one of many expenses had been dismissed. A spokesman for the Fort Bend County District Legal professional’s mentioned that Alaniz’s cost was dropped due to inadequate proof. 

The costs in opposition to Christine Saenz had been dismissed “within the curiosity of justice,” mentioned the district legal professional’s spokesperson, Wesley Wittig. Wittig added that it wasn’t clear what that meant, and extra recordsdata that would make clear the dismissal weren’t instantly obtainable. 

The costs in opposition to Steven Saenz had been lowered to misdemeanor resisting, and he pleaded responsible and was given time served, Wittig mentioned.

The Saenzes declined to be interviewed, however the lawyer who dealt with their civil rights swimsuit, Robert Whitley, mentioned the swimsuit was settled in 2017 for an undisclosed quantity.

Steven Saenz’s nostril was damaged within the altercation, the swimsuit says, and each he and his spouse suffered concussions.

“These cops had been off the charts,” Whitley mentioned. “They blew this complete state of affairs up. It’s the type of factor that makes your blood boil.”


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Friday MEGA MILLIONS® jackpot is $660 million