A massive $188 bn exodus shows China’s heft fading in world markets

By Jeanny Yu and Charlotte Yang

A large retreat of funds from Chinese language shares and bonds is diminishing the market’s clout in international portfolios and accelerating its decoupling from the remainder of the world.

International holdings of the nation’s equities and debt have fallen by about 1.37 trillion yuan ($188 billion), or 17%, from a December-2021 peak by way of the tip of June this 12 months, in response to Bloomberg calculations based mostly on the most recent knowledge from the central financial institution. That’s earlier than onshore shares witnessed a document $12 billion outflow in August alone.

The exodus coincides with China’s financial droop attributable to years of Covid restrictions, a property market disaster, and protracted tensions with the West — considerations which have helped make the “keep away from China” theme one of many largest convictions amongst traders in Financial institution of America’s newest survey. International fund participation within the Hong Kong inventory market has dropped by greater than a 3rd for the reason that finish of 2020.

“Foreigners are simply dropping out,” mentioned Zhikai Chen, head of Asia and international EM equities at BNP Paribas Asset Administration. There’s nervousness concerning the property market and a slowdown in client spending, he mentioned. “Disappointment on these fronts has led to a variety of international traders rethinking their publicity.”

A massive $188 bn exodus shows China's heft fading in world markets

Whereas China’s weak point was as soon as seen as dragging down the remainder of the world, notably the emerging-markets group, that has clearly not been the case this 12 months. Down about 7% in 2023, the MSCI China Index is watching a 3rd straight 12 months of losses that can mark the longest shedding streak in over 20 years. The broader MSCI Rising Markets Index is up 3% as traders chase returns somewhere else like India and components of Latin America.

The divergence comes as China’s bid to realize self-sufficiency throughout provide chains and souring ties with the US have made different markets much less inclined to its ebbs and flows. Along with the financial decoupling, one more reason has been the factitious intelligence increase, which has boosted markets from the US to Taiwan whereas giving much less of a raise to mainland shares. China’s weighting within the EM gauge has dropped to round 27% from greater than 30% on the finish of 2021.

On the similar time, a technique of stripping China out of emerging-market portfolios is quick gaining traction, with launches of fairness funds that exclude China already reaching a document annual excessive in 2023.

“China dangers are a number of – LGFV, housing inventory overhang, demographics, dependency ratio, regulatory volatility, geopolitical isolation,” mentioned Gaurav Pantankar, chief funding officer at MercedCERA, which oversees roughly $1.1 billion of property within the US. “Funding alternatives inside EM exist in varied pockets.”


Within the debt market, international traders have pulled about $26 billion from Chinese language authorities bonds in 2023, whereas plowing a collective $62 billion into notes from the remainder of rising Asia, knowledge compiled by Bloomberg present. Roughly half of the $250 billion-$300 billion influx that accompanied China’s inclusion into authorities bond indexes since 2019 has been erased, in response to an evaluation by JPMorgan Chase & Co.

Promoting stress on the yuan has pushed the foreign money to a 16-year low versus the greenback. The central financial institution’s unfastened coverage stance, in distinction to tightening in most main economies, is weakening the yuan and giving foreigners one more reason to shun native property.

When it comes to company debt efficiency, China seems to have totally decoupled from the remainder of Asia as a disaster in its actual property sector heads into its fourth 12 months. The market has change into extra locally-held with roughly 85-90% owned by home traders.

All of this comes towards the backdrop of China’s deteriorating economic system, which has brought about a rethink of the market’s attract as an funding vacation spot. Wall Road banks together with Citigroup Inc. and JPMorgan doubt whether or not Beijing’s 5% development goal for this 12 months may be met.

But the gargantuan measurement of China’s economic system and its key function within the manufacturing provide chain imply the market will stay an important a part of portfolios for a lot of traders, albeit to a lesser extent.

One channel by way of which China can nonetheless affect worldwide monetary markets is by way of globally traded commodities. Being the most important importer of power, metals and meals, its affect extends past securities portfolios, creating ties to the worldwide economic system which can be prone to show extra sturdy. The nation’s world-leading place in clear power, from photo voltaic panels to electrical automobiles, is one instance of the expanded potential for commerce because the world tries to fulfill its local weather obligations.

“An economic system which slows down doesn’t achieve this in every single place,” mentioned Karine Hirn, accomplice at East Capital Asset Administration. “We discover good worth in sectors with structural development outlook, comparable to new power automobiles, consumer-related and components of renewables provide chain.”


The CSI 300 Index, a benchmark of onshore shares, fell 0.7% on Friday as foreigners offered even after knowledge on retail gross sales and industrial manufacturing for August exceeded estimates. Because the weak point persists, international funds’ positioning in China has already reached the bottom degree since October, when the nation’s reopening from stringent Covid curbs sparked a pointy rebound over the following three months. In distinction, allocation to US equities — which have outperformed international friends this 12 months — is rising.

For cash managers like Xin-Yao Ng, investing in China requires a delicate steadiness of being cautious of the structural challenges whereas looking for alternatives from particular person shares.

“I’m structurally cautious about China’s long-term financial outlook, and aware of fatter tail dangers referring to geopolitics,” mentioned Ng, an funding supervisor of Asian equities at abrdn Asia Ltd. “However China remains to be a really large and deep universe with a variety of completely different alternatives. Broad valuation may be very low now,” he mentioned, including that it’s an “attention-grabbing inventory selecting market” for elementary traders.